On Oct. 16, A24 released the documentary You Can See Everything in theaters to critical praise and strong audience reception. In April 2023, Elizabeth Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans, approached A24 to make a documentary about her life, leading co-directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim to start production 34 days before Holmes reported to federal prison. While living with Holmes and Evans, Fielder examines Holmes’ character and morals as well as how she interprets the truth.

Holmes was convicted in January 2022 on one count of conspiracy to defraud investors and three counts of wire fraud, both for her company Theranos’ misleading representations of its blood testing technology and partnerships with the U.S. military and pharmaceutical companies like Pfizer.

Elliott and Tim’s Rating: 5/5 – We were pretty excited going into the theater, but this film well exceeded our expectations. This is clearly one of the best movies hitting theaters this year and the best documentary we have ever seen.

Spoiler-free Review

As the movie starts, Holmes and Evans are discussing an article written about her in The New York Times. As Fielder inquires about a quote that was challenged by Holmes as being falsely attributed to her, we see the first example of tense moments between Fielder and Holmes where neither the audience nor Fielder can tell if she is lying. Although most conversations by this point are friendly, Fielder shows his expertise in making moments uncomfortable and revealing his subjects’ true nature. These moments where Fielder presses Holmes are effective at engaging the audience, and for us, they were among the most fun parts to watch.

You Can See Everything poster. Credit: A24

While Fielder is living at the estate, he shows Holmes a famous comedy routine, “Who’s on First.” He then asks Holmes if she understands what is funny about this routine, which she can’t seem to decipher. Evans immediately steps in to clarify that she struggles to understand basic communication, which is something that they reiterate throughout the film. At a glance, it looks like an innocent conversation, but as the film goes on, it appears that it may be an elaborate lie. Considering Holmes’ crimes of defrauding investors, her being a poor communicator could make her appear innocent.

Another display of Fielder’s expertise is when he shows Holmes and Evans the Hulu original series The Dropout, which is a fictional, dramatized retelling of the Theranos story. While watching it, Holmes expresses how uncomfortable she is and that the show was a distasteful representation of her life, adding to the sympathy that Fielder and the audience may have for her.

Some of the things that made this film feel so immersive and intense have to do with how it was filmed: The filming crew used a three-camera setup with two zoom lenses following Fielder and his interview subject at the time, as well as one wide-lens camera capturing the layout of this house. This allowed them to get incredible close-ups of Holmes and Evans’ faces, which lets the audience try to analyze their expressions in hopes of sorting out what’s the truth and what’s a lie.

Another element of the film that stood out to us was composer Ari Balouzian’s original score, which we thought was incredible. The music was reminiscent of a horror movie or thriller, as the strings, piano, and synth music were chilling and haunting; it completely amplified every tense moment, adding an incredible atmosphere to the scenes.

Spoiler Review

After Holmes was sent to prison, Fielder reached out to Amanda Seyfried, who played Holmes in The Dropout, to watch the film up to that point and to also recreate interactions with Elizabeth that he and Oppenheim couldn’t film. This decision is morally questionable, as Holmes expressed her distaste for the actor, questioning how a woman could “do that” to another woman. We thought that this part of the film was really interesting because it almost felt like a new movie.

Another fascinating development was when Fielder interviewed Evans in his office, as Evans revealed that he created an AI model of Holmes for public use and that he has the power of attorney over Holmes’ social media, where he frequently posts and replies to people on her behalf. We were flabbergasted when this was revealed, especially because of the moral implications of Evans completely taking over Holmes’ social media presence and posting things that Fielder and Seyfried agreed she would never say. Moments like this really contributed to a feeling of discovery, which kept us and the rest of the audience engaged.

Altogether, You Can See Everything was an incredible combination of tense moments, deceit, unintentional comedy, and a desperate billionaire trying to save her tarnished reputation.

Article By Elliott Gardner and Tim Polishuck